Navigating The Mindfield
Party wall practice under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 frequently pushes surveyors into complex jurisdictional waters. When an award goes wrong, or when circumstances change halfway through a project, surveyors face critical questions: What happens when an award contains errors or omissions? Where does a tribunal’s authority start and end? And can a party wall surveyor actually be sued for getting it wrong?
At the Maidenhead Forum, these central themes were dissected to examine how jurisdiction works, the debate over functus officio, and the true extent of surveyor immunity.
1. The Boundaries of Jurisdiction: Deemed Disputes & Making Good
To judge whether an award contains an error or an omission, one must first determine if the statutory tribunal acted intra vires (within its power). Under section 10(10) of the 1996 Act, a dispute exists when building owners and adjoining owners disagree “in respect of any matter connected with any work to which this Act relates”.
A primary area of confusion involves deemed disputes under notice provisions—such as Section 3 (Party Structure Notice), Section 4 (Counter Notice), and Section 6 (Excavation Notice).
The Lea Valley Contradiction
In Lea Valley Developments Ltd v Derbyshire [2017], surveyors included a clause requiring a building owner to make good structural damage arising from Section 6 excavation works or pay monies in lieu. The court remarked that this was ultra vires because Section 6—unlike Section 2—does not explicitly mention a right to “make good”.
However, a closer legal reading suggests this analysis missed the mark. While Section 6 does not explicitly state a right to make good, Section 10(10) grants jurisdiction over any matter connected with any work to which the Act relates. An adjoining owner who dissents under Section 6(7) often does so out of concern over structural damage. Addressing potential damage by requiring remediation or payment in lieu is directly connected to the authorized works and falls squarely within the scope of a deemed dispute.
2. What Belongs in an Award (and What Must Be Excluded)?
A party wall tribunal’s mandate is strictly defined under section 10(12) to cover:
The right to execute work.
The time and manner of executing work.
Any other matter arising out of or incidental to the dispute (including award costs).
Key Jurisdictional Ground Rules
Determining Notice Validity: A tribunal can determine the validity of initial notices (Loost v Kramer). However, if a notice is genuinely invalid, surveyors lack statutory jurisdiction to make a binding award.
Timing of Objections: Parties must object to notice validity or surveyor appointments early; otherwise, courts may find those objections waived (Manu v Euroview Estates Ltd).
Limits on Cost Awards: Section 10(13) allows recovery of reasonable costs for making the award and inspecting works, but costs connected to external civil court proceedings cannot be awarded (Blake v Reeves).
Retrospective Awards: If work starts before service of notice or before the statutory notice period expires, a retrospective award can bring work within the statutory framework. However, it does not bar the adjoining owner from pursuing common law civil claims for prior damage (Louis v Sadiq, Rodrigues v Sokal).
3. The Functus Officio Debate: Can Surveyors Issue Multiple Awards?
Once a primary party wall award is signed, does the tribunal’s authority vanish?
Decisions by Judge Parfitt in K Group Holdings v Saidco and Fernando v London Borough of Newham suggested that issuing an award renders surveyors functus officio (their mandate is fulfilled and ended). Under this strict interpretation, any further addendum award would be made without jurisdiction.
There are strong statutory and practical counter-arguments to this view:
Legislative Intent: The 1996 Act was intended to extend the Inner London framework (London Building Acts (Amendment) Act 1939) nationally and modernize language, not restrict jurisdiction. Section 55(i) of the 1939 Act expressly permitted surveyors to settle disputes “from time to time during the continuance of such work”.
Practicality and Cost: Requiring parties to reappoint a new tribunal for every subsequent disagreement during construction creates unnecessary delay and expense.
Statutory Phrasing: The 1996 Act consistently uses open phrasing: “any matter” (s.10(10)), “the disputed matters” (s.10(11)), and making “an award” rather than “the award” (s.10(14), s.10(15)).
Appellate Precedent: The Court of Appeal has repeatedly acknowledged the necessity of subsequent/addendum awards (Zissis v Lukomski, Blake v Reeves).
Best Practice Advisory: Surveyors should ensure their initial Section 10(2) written appointments explicitly cover all disputes arising under the relevant notice throughout the duration of the works.
4. Negligence, Immunity, and Bad Faith: Are Surveyors Liable?
If an award contains a clear error, can a disgruntled owner sue the party wall surveyor in professional negligence?
TRIBUNAL LIABILITY FRAMEWORK
│
┌────────────────────────────┴────────────────────────────┐
▼ ▼
Negligence Claim Statutory Appeal
(Caparo v Dickman Test) (Section 10(17))
│ │
No Duty of Care 14-Day Appeal Window
(Gray v Crawley) (Rehearing by Court)
Duty of Care and Negligence
In Gray v Crawley, Judge Parfitt applied the three-fold test from Caparo v Dickman and concluded that party wall surveyors do not owe a duty of care in negligence to the parties. Because the surveyor’s statutory function is dispute resolution and an statutory appeal route exists under Section 10(17), imposing a common law duty of care is neither fair nor reasonable.
Do Surveyors Have Quasi-Judicial Immunity?
Judicial opinion remains split on surveyor immunity:
Immune: Judge Parfitt in Gray v Crawley viewed surveyors as quasi-arbitrators holding immunity.
Not Immune: Sir Michael Burton in RICS v Antino conducted a thorough analysis and concluded that party wall surveyors do not enjoy arbitral immunity.
While Sir Michael Burton’s analysis offers a persuasive perspective on immunity, the underlying holding of Gray v Crawley—that no duty of care exists under the Caparo test—remains an obstacle for negligence claims against surveyors.
Bad Faith and the “Slip Rule”
By comparison, Section 29 of the Arbitration Act 1996 grants arbitrators statutory immunity except for acts or omissions in bad faith. If a party wall surveyor acts in bad faith, civil liability remains a distinct possibility.
For minor administrative errors or accidental omissions, tribunals can rely on the principle of the “slip rule” (reflected in CPR r 40.12(1)), which allows formal correction of genuine accidental slips without invalidating the underlying determination.





